Quantcast Washington Square News

April 10th, 2008

On Last Night’s “South Park” [12.05 “Eek, A Penis!”]

By Matt Margini

Allow me to start with a dick joke exegesis. Comedian Patrice O’Neal once said, on an episode of “Tough Crowd with Colin Quinn” (a great show, and one of Comedy Central’s most tragic and ill-advised abortions), that comedy was all about hard consonants. Words with natural bite–rhetorical effectiveness at the most elementary, molecular level. I don’t know if it was his theory, though I do consider him an urban Buddha of sorts so I wouldn’t be surprised. At the time, it seemed like the kind of beautiful simplicity that pours only out of the unclogged font of Nirvana.

I’m down with “South Park” deciding, in its position as God and Emperor of all things completely fucking puerile, to fill up the vast majority of its most recent episode with a recurring dick joke. Especially when the premise is this gloriously bizarre: Mrs. Garrison, having decided in her infinite sexual disorientation to revert back to manhood, commissions a lab to grow a penis for her on the back of a mouse. Personally, I would bag it and tag it right there–magnificent, timeless dick joke achieved. But that’s just the setup. The mouse then escapes, prompting a wild slapstick adventure all around town as Garrison chases it and women everywhere scream “Eek! A Penis!” when it scampers (and flops) into view. And it’s in that extended second act that the dick joke loses its balance and falls on its greasy face.

If O’Neal is in any way correct–and I suspect he is, because his comedy affirms his philosophy–then the word “dick” is funny in and of itself. But that’s not necessarily true for “penis.” You can complain about the structure and content of the joke all you want (and here, I’ll do just that: women standing on stools and shrieking to avoid mice, or anything, hasn’t been funny since “Tom & Jerry” antiquity, and in general the entire thing is a bloated mess). But the real problem is the eponymous phrase, which is repeated and relied upon like a verbal crutch–”Eek, A Penis!” is just not inherently funny. Maybe it’s funny in a British accent (O’Neal’s rule largely sidesteps the issue of the speaker himself), but it’s just not funny here.

The other roughly-30% of this episode was a parody of “Stand and Deliver” and all those other insufferable movies with overextended teachers trying to reach inner-city kids. Cartman is sent to a Denver public school, where he struggles to teach urban youths how to “cheat like white people.” This segment was great when it trained its crosshair on the more general features of a limping, feeble, and largely bankrupt genre, and when it dispensed that particularly cynical message. Not so great, on the other hand, when it specifically mocked “Stand and Deliver,” which hasn’t been part of the pop-cultural lexicon since the 90s. Oh well, missed opportunities and fumbled executions still imply ambition, I think. If nothing else, “South Park” aspires to dick joke greatness.

This entry was posted on Thursday, April 10th, 2008 at 3:55 pm and is filed under Arts, TV. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

29 Responses to “On Last Night’s “South Park” [12.05 “Eek, A Penis!”]”

  1. cash advance…

    Cash advance easy way to get payday loan
    Uk mortgages
    Uk mortgage
    Uk home mortgages
    Small business loan
    Secured credit cards
    Second mortgage
    Reverse mortgage
    Refinance
    Quickest cash advance
    Personal loan
    Payday loans
    Payday loan
    Payday loa…

  2. Poker chips…

    Michigan lottery

    Michigan lottery results

    Massachusetts lottery

    Mega millions lottery

    Mass state lottery

    Mass lottery

    Maryland lottery

    March madness betting

    Maine state lottery

    Ma lottery

    Louisiana lottery

    Lottery

    Lo…

  3. Poker chips…

    Michigan lottery

    Michigan lottery results

    Massachusetts lottery

    Mega millions lottery

    Mass state lottery

    Mass lottery

    Maryland lottery

    March madness betting

    Maine state lottery

    Ma lottery

    Louisiana lottery

    Lottery

    Lo…

  4. California state lottery…

    Bingo

    Bingo supplies

    Bingo cards

  5. Texas holdem…

    Texas holdem…

  6. Slot machines…

    Slot machine…

  7. Poker Online…

    Online poker…

  8. Carmelita…

    Some weblog software programs, such as Wordpress, Movable Type and Community Server, support automatic pingbacks where all the links…

  9. Crazy Penis…

    Teacher: Tell me a sentence that starts with an “I”. Student: I is the…. Teacher: Stop! Never put ‘is’ after an “I”. Always put ‘am’ after an “I”. Student: OK. I am the ninth letter of the alphabet.:)…

  10. Online Poker Sites…

    Online Poker Sites
    Casino Games
    Play Poker
    Online Gambling
    Keno
    Free Slots
    Top Online Casinos…

  11. Blackberry Ringtones…

    Christian Ringtones

    Cingular Ringtones

    Cingular wireless Ringtones

  12. Totally free Ringtones…

    Nascar Ringtones

    Nextel Ringtones

    Nokia Ringtone

  13. Boy Penis…

    Customer: Excuse me, but I saw your thumb in my soup when you were carrying it. Waitress: Oh, that’s okay. The soup isn’t hot. :)…

  14. Ringtone software…

    Crazy frog Ringtone

    Create Ringtones

    Cricket Ringtones

  15. searchgals…

    loguestbook

    loli hc bbs

    lolikon

    lorcet addiction

    loseweight

    love poems

    lovpop

    ls-magazine

    lubeyourtube

    luclinks

    lupaland

    lusty puppy

    lustypuppy

    lynchburg virginia

    m90

    made easy hyip

    madmamas

    madthumbs

  16. Bad Credit Loans Personal Loan Auto Loan Calculator…

    I can not agree with you in 100% regarding some thoughts, but you got good point of view…

  17. Advance Loan Maryland Payday…

    I have to say, that I could not agree with you in 100%, but it’s just my opinion, which could be wrong….

  18. Funny Penis…

    The search for the truth is the most important work in the whole world — and the most dangerous. ~ James Clavell…

  19. Dolly Williams…

    I think you are absolutely on track here!…

  20. Ma Mortgage…

    Lol, this is what it’s come down to these days, “I wonder what language…

  21. Mortgage Calculator Currency Conversion Financing…

    I didn’t agree with you first, but last paragraph makes sense for me…

  22. Marketing Direct Mail Marketing Add Link…

    I didn’t agree with you first, but last paragraph makes sense for me…

  23. Software Software Test Discount Software…

    I didn’t agree with you first, but last paragraph makes sense for me…

  24. nascar slots…

    It has since been implemented in most other blogging tools. One notable blogging tool that does not support trackback yet is Blogger. This…

  25. My Cracks and Serials…

    I can not agree with you in 100% regarding some thoughts, but you got good point of view…

  26. Louisiana Universities…

    As a result, TrackBack spam filters similar to those implemented against comment spam now exist in many weblog publishing systems….

  27. So who’s the retard who keeps spamming “I didn’t agree with you first, but last paragraph makes sense for me…”

    This stupid comment is everywhere. It’s sooo obviously fake. The worst spam is from people who don’t know enough English to type a decent sentence. How stupid are you, spammer??

  28. OH oh oh, here’s another brainless spam comment “you got good point of view…”

    Brilliant. Brilliantly stupid, that is. LEARN ENGLISH you fool spammer.

Leave a Reply

Advertisement

Poll

What are you doing this summer?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement